Friday, June 16, 2017

A Comedy Romance in Pantomime

City Lights is a sound movie in pantomime.  There's a synchronized sound-track with many sound-effects, most obviously the kazoo-speech of the worthy's dedicating the statue at the beginning of the picture, the bells ringing in the boxing-match sequence, and the shots fired in the Millionaire's house.  These are examples of what's come to be called (wrongly but almost universally) diagetic sound, sound common to the world of the fiction and the world of the audience.  Non-diagetic sound (now) designates sound that only we hear: scary mood music when someone is exploring a haunted house that seems (to them) completely silent, for example, swelling strings when two lovers are about to kiss.

In some movies we can't tell whether the sound we're hearing is part of the fictional world: usually the surprise will be that it is, that music that we think is only for us turns out to be coming from a radio or a performer we hadn't seen.  And sometimes -- maybe most famously in the 1946 version of The Killers -- there's an interplay between the diagetic and non-diagetic music, so that the Green Cat piano-player's performance of Flight of the Bumblebee strikingly interacts with the Killers-leitmotif when they enter the bar.

But (as I noticed the other day) the opposite sort of thing happens in City Lights.  As with the three-decades of silent films it mimics and closes, there's plenty of sound in the world of the film that we in the real world don't hear.  Sound movies invert the relationship of sound to world that we find in silent movies.  Not quite -- while in silent movies all we can hear is non-diagetic sound, it is true that the silent characters don't hear that sound at all.  All they hear is diagetic sound -- to use a double solecism because this is sound we don't hear.

City Lights is the real inverse, though.  We and the boxers both hear the bell; we and the robbers both hear the gun go off.  And of course we hear all the non-diagetic music that we learned to listen for from silents, if not from opera and ballet, which the characters don't.

But the Blind Girl: what she hears we don't.  She plays a record on the phonograph, but the soundtrack music doesn't change.  More significantly, in the intensely reworked scene in which the Tramp, and the audience, come to realize that she's blind, we see her respond to the slamming of a car door that we don't hear, at about 8:35 into the movie (there doesn't seem to be a good way to start just at that point in this post but you can click on this link to start it at just the right place: https://youtu.be/TkF1we_DeCQ?t=8m35s )


You'll see her react to the slamming door, but we don't hear it slam: we just see it.

I think it's important that we never hear what she's hearing.  The Tramp can see but he can also hear and we can hear with him, just as we can hear with everyone else.  We can see that she can hear but we never hear what she's hearing, which means that we focus on her bodily relation to the world, on her touch.

At the end of the movie, when she sees the Tramp for the first time, there's no reason for her to recognize him.  But she would be able to recognize his voice, and that would be the natural recognition scene. And it wouldn't work.

What matters is that she should recognize him through touch, when unknowingly she gives him the change that she failed to give him before.  Now she can see, and the days of touch are over: we can see them touch for the last time.  All of this requires that the movie be silent, be a pantomime, so that the self-presence of sound doesn't enter into it.

It's another version of Orpheus and Eurydice, that central myth in which sight overwhelms sound -- the song that Orpheus sings -- with the result that touch is banished forever.    He looks back at her and loses her forever, sees her going but will never touch her again.  The happiest version is in Purgatorio: Dante looks back at Virgil, and he's gone, and so are his sweet songs; but he can truly see Beatrice now, though touch is no longer a relevant sense in the Comedy.  City Lights isn't the saddest version, but it is an exceptionally clear exposition of that moment when the pantomime has ended.

13 comments:

  1. Dich cho thue acc battleground uy tin ban co the thue acc pubg moi cach nhanh chong , cung thue acc battleground de trai nghiem nhe

    thue acc pubg gia re choi tet ga

    ReplyDelete
  2. Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon. Big thanks for the useful info  gomovies free

    ReplyDelete
  3. I appreciate several from the Information which has been composed, and especially the remarks posted I will visit once more.  Soame Chopra is a highly entertaining guy

    ReplyDelete
  4. 70-533 exam questions - Get up-to-date real exam questions for 70-533 Implementing Microsoft Azure Infrastructure Solutions. Access online the Q&A and get ready

    ReplyDelete
  5. As you are looking on the Internet for stand-up comedy tips? Please be aware that the techniques and strategies offered in many stand-up comedy tips simply don't work Heather Land I aint doint T Shirt

    ReplyDelete
  6. As you are looking on the Internet for stand-up comedy tips? Please be aware that the techniques and strategies offered in many stand-up comedy tips simply don't work Prank Postcards

    ReplyDelete
  7. Information on on how Canadian business owners and financing managers can access inventory financing lenders for cash flow based financing and additional working capital. Requirements to initiate an inventory and PO finance strategy for your firm. spooky scary skeletons dance

    ReplyDelete
  8. Information on on how Canadian business owners and financing managers can access inventory financing lenders for cash flow based financing and additional working capital. Requirements to initiate an inventory and PO finance strategy for your firm. new york city

    ReplyDelete
  9. n a country where money is to be made from pills, treatment facilities and medical aid schemes, hypnosis, one of the most effective ways for dealing with physical and mental ills today, is hardly mentioned. Yet a recent survey shows that a year after undergoing hypnosis interventions, 77 percent of clients that were drug addiction treatment

    ReplyDelete
  10. When talking about business related issues, solutions, and technologies, you will almost always group businesses as small and large. While the separation is there, it won't be wrong to say that in a modern where digital technologies prevail, it should not be a problem for small businesses to compete with large ones. local electrician

    ReplyDelete
  11. The fashion industry is a glamorous field with immense earning potential as well as the chance to create a name and status. But all of these require hard work and obviously a professional diploma or degree from a reputed fashion institute in India. Arts

    ReplyDelete
  12. World Facts For Children… [...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]… 먹튀폴리스

    ReplyDelete
  13. World Facts For Children… [...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]… Orlando

    ReplyDelete